How exposed is the Scottish Government on data centres?

“People are secretive when they have secrets.” Deb Caletti

This blog post previously appeared in The National as part of Common Weal’s In Common newsletter.

If you’d like to support my work for Common Weal or support me and this blog directly, see my donation policy page here.

An activist at an anti-data centre protest holding a placard saying "Invest in community. No hyperscale AI datacenter please"

News landed this week that the Scottish Government, via Scottish Enterprise, were manoeuvring themselves out of their controversial deals surrounding the Dalzell steel works in Motherwell (no family relation, that’s just where the seat of the clan used to be). It was announced early in the week that the £7 million the Government had given to Liberty Steel had been “paid back” but a few days later it was revealed that the loan had actually been swapped for a stake in a speculative data centre developer that was founded only two years ago. The precise details of the long web of financial dealings to allow the Government to “pay back” that loan by taking an equity stake elsewhere are too complex to summarise here and many of the details are still hidden from public view due to “commercial sensitivities” that should never apply when public money is involved.

With severe signs that the global AI bubble is close to popping we really should be asking why the Government is tying itself and our public finances to the fate of that bubble.

Common Weal has been calling for governments to start taking more equity stakes in companies in Scotland for a number of years now and see it as a much better system than merely giving out grants or even giving out loans that do not give the government a direct hand in how its investments are managed, but there has always been an important aspect to this that I do not believe has been met in this case.

Where we have called for equity stakes, it has been in sectors involved with vital or foundational sectors in the economy that have a more than reasonable chance of making a return on that investment, especially where that return may only be realised in a time scale longer than more speculative finance is comfortable with.

“The Scottish Government is trying to get out of its own leaking rowing boat of a bad steel deal by climbing onto the Titanic.”

This means that government should absolutely be investing in social housing (which may not pay back its investment for several decades but which would then return an income or provide cheaper rents to tenants for generations afterwards) and they should absolutely be investing public stakes in energy (which will always have a demand and where it is clear that energy companies are, quite frankly, profiteering from Scottish households due to the lack of Scottish public energy companies).

There’s even a case for equity stakes in primary manufacturing like steel plants – controversies over the particular case of Dalzell aside.

This was why when we originally designed the Scottish National Investment Bank we called for its investment portfolio to be based primarily on housing and energy, which would give the Bank the fiscal security to invest a little more speculatively in interesting but uncertain Scottish startups or suchlike.

None of this applies to taking stakes in AI data centres. As tech journalist Cory Doctorow has pointed out, this sector is making the largest monetary losses of any industrial development in history. The speculative bubble has inflated to the point that it has sucked the life out of the electronics sector harder than the impact of the Covid pandemic (when everyone upgraded their PCs to work from home – now, no-one can buy the chips they need to replace those PCs and tech billionaires like Sam Altman are telling everyone that they shouldn’t because their RAM would be ‘more efficiently used’ if he owned the chips and rented them back to you), and Nvidia, one of the few companies that is actually profiting because they make the chips, is right now suffering a severe scandal because it appears that their CEO has had an affair with a spy [Note, since writing this article, Jensen Huang has resigned as CEO of Nvidia]. Anthropic, another of the big AI players, has slashed its company valuation in half right before its proposed initial public offering compared to values being floated in the summer and even that may be a substantial overreach given that a traditional valuation based on their “price to sales ratio” doesn’t work for a company that its losing $10 billion per month and promises to keep doing so for another three years.

None of this is sustainable, and the Scottish Government is trying to get out of its own leaking rowing boat of a bad steel deal by climbing onto the Titanic.

In our column here last week Robin pointed out some of the misinformed points being promoted by the Scottish Government’s Minister for AI and Strategy. We need to ask where his department is on this deal. What is the strategic plan for investment in AI data centres right at the point where the bubble may be popping? In addition to this equity stake, how exposed is the Scottish Government to other investments in AI? Has their been any strategic thinking on the broader economic impact if and when the bubble pops? Or how we can protect Scottish households from the negative impacts of that happening?

We cannot just hope that the promises of the benefits of AI will come true and that none of the negative consequences will. We also cannot properly evaluate the soundness of economic and investment strategy in AI when the details are so murky or are outright blocked from public view. The Scottish Government must do more to explain precise what they think they’re doing with investments like this and what, precisely, they hope to achieve.

The Common Green logo Green text on a dark green background, above a version of the Common Weal "balance" logo.

How we should regulate Data Centres

“The destiny of intelligent tool-using life was to be a stepping-stone in the evolution of corporate instruments.” – Charles Stross (Accelerando)

This blog post previously appeared in The National as part of Common Weal’s In Common newsletter.

If you’d like to support my work for Common Weal or support me and this blog directly, see my donation policy page here.

A stock photo of the inside of a data centre under construction, showing a row of empty racks and loose cables.

There’s an increasingly loud uprising happening in Scotland around AI data centres. Possibly the biggest I’ve seen since the 2016 uproar over shale gas fracking.

Data centre companies are actively lobbying the Scottish Government as we speak and are basically asking for John Swinney to open the gates to them to flood Scotland with as many data centres as he’s willing to make us all swallow. It’s easy to see what the companies get out of it. Scotland has plenty of space, a good amount of water and while electricity prices are high they can often negotiate preferential rates that we could only dream of. What does Scotland get out of it? Higher energy prices, higher demand on increasingly scare water, about three-and-a-half jobs, and the Scottish Government gets to claim that the “inwards investment” line goes up?

Perhaps I can see why Swinney would take that deal.

Most insidiously, the companies appear to be lobbying to write their own environmental laws. Just as with Freeports, their goal will be to effectively deregulate themselves either by getting specific exemptions from regulations or for the Government to allow themselves to internally self-regulate without outside interference (which would amount to the same thing).

“I’m pretty sure that none of the suggestions I’m about to make are in any way objectionable to anyone who doesn’t want to actively harm Scotland’s people or environment.”

We should demand that the Government holds them to the highest possible standards. I can give you a few bullet points and ideas to take to your MSPs – whether or not you have a data centre looming over you at the moment. I’m pretty sure that none of the suggestions I’m about to make are in any way objectionable to anyone who doesn’t want to actively harm Scotland’s people or environment.

1) Energy

In order that the energy demands of the data centre do not increase prices for the people of Scotland, to be approved, a data centre must meet at least one and possibly more of the following:

a) The data centre must be entirely off-grid and powered with zero-carbon energy. This must include emergency backups such as batteries as we do not want to repeat the case being seen in America where a lack of grid connections is prompting data centre companies to install massively polluting private gas and diesel generators.

b) If grid-connected, the data centre must fund the construction of enough zero-carbon energy generators to meet its own projected needs. These generators must be installed and operating before the data centre is allowed to draw energy from the grid.

c) The data centre company must fund the construction of enough zero-carbon energy generators, with those constructed generators being donated free-of-charge to Scottish public or community ownership to offset the demands the centre will make on the grid. An alternative or complement to this would be the data centre company installing, at their own cost, rooftop solar panels on Scottish homes starting with homes living in fuel poverty.

2) Heat

The waste heat from a data centre must be captured and redirected into a local District Heating Network. If a heat network is not currently installed in the local area, the centre must be designed to plug into such a network when one becomes available. In this case, funding the construction of such a network may be counted as a contribution towards energy infrastructure requirements.

3) Water

The data centre must “do no harm” to water systems. Any water drawn from municipal networks must occur only after local residential and other essential needs are met, with the company funding the construction of additional strengthening of the water network if necessary. Additionally, waste water from the data centre must not be released into the environment or into waste networks in a less than human drinkable state.

4) Materials

In addition to usual planning requirements around local jobs and material supply, the data centre – both the building itself and the materials for the computers inside – must be designed to Net Zero and to Circular Economy standards. All materials (especially those containing critical minerals such as the computers) must be designed to minimise waste and to be reused, repurposed or remanufactured into commercial-grade products at the end of their useful life. All materials that cannot be repurposed must be compostable or fully recyclable. No materials should go to landfill or incineration.

5) Social costs

The owners shall recognise the social harms their centres and the products they are used for may cause. All social costs shall be calculated (this will include but not be limited to carbon emissions, other pollution, displacement of jobs and breaches of IP laws). The cost of these harms will be placed in bond by the company as a condition of planning approval and the bond shall be insured with unlimited liability against overruns.

Additionally, if the computers within the centre are involved in criminal activity not directly attributable to an individual (such as mass IP breaches or hacks involving rogue AIs) then the Directors of the data centre company shall accept legal liability as if they had personally committed, aided or abetted said crimes.

Will Scotland do this?

I certainly don’t think any of the conditions above are particularly controversial so I believe that the Scottish Government should be able to support these or similar as certain minimum conditions. If the data centres can meet them, then we can move on to asking questions about what use they will actually be used for and how that use will benefit the people of Scotland.

This answer to this question will be different for, for example, a centre handling NHS patient data to avoid sending that data to privacy hostile nations like the USA than it will be for an AI hyperscaler owned by a equality hostile US billionaire. In either case though, the buildings themselves have the potential to cause great harm and this must be minimised and prevented. If they can’t do this, they should not be built.

The Common Green logo Green text on a dark green background, above a version of the Common Weal "balance" logo.